Who Did It Better
The Original -- 1973
<p>The song is about the specific vulnerability of being seen too clearly by someone else. Roberta Flack recorded it as a quiet masterpiece of observation, the narrator realizing that the man across the room has been reading her the entire time and there is nowhere to hide. Killing me softly... with his song. The murder weapon is understanding. The narrator is not in danger. She is exposed, and the exposure feels worse than any threat because it reveals parts of herself she did not know were visible.</p> <p>That same exposure gets a generational redefinition in the Fugees' 1996 version, with Lauryn Hill on lead vocals. Where Roberta's original is a solo piano ballad, intimate and sparse, the Fugees turn the song into a hip-hop soul hybrid that announces the arrival of a new kind of voice. Lauryn's vocal carries the same vulnerability as Roberta's but it is filtered through a different set of experiences ... a woman who has been watched, analyzed, and underestimated by people who thought they could see her. The rhythm track, built around a sample that connects the 70s to the 90s, gives the song a heartbeat that Roberta's version never needed. Lauryn does not just sing about being killed softly. She sounds like she has survived the killing and is telling you about it from the other side, stronger, clearer, more dangerous than before.</p>
The Cover -- 1996
Lauryn Hill on lead vocals. Where Roberta's original is a solo piano ballad, intimate and sparse, the Fugees turn the song into a hip-hop soul hybrid that announces the arrival of a new kind of voice. Lauryn's vocal carries the same vulnerability as Roberta's but it is filtered through a different set of experiences ... a woman who has been watched, analyzed, and underestimated by people who thought they could see her. The rhythm track, built around a sample that connects the 70s to the 90s, gives the song a heartbeat that Roberta's version never needed. Lauryn does not just sing about being killed softly. She sounds like she has survived the killing and is telling you about it from the other side, stronger, clearer, more dangerous than before.</p>